United States District Court, E.D. Louisiana
IN THE MATTER OF GIS MARINE, LLC AS OWNER OF THE M/V GIS CRUSADER PETITIONING FOR EXONERATION FROM OR LIMITATION OF LIABILITY C/w No. 15-1133-ILRL-SS
SALLY SHUSHAN, Magistrate Judge.
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER (Rec. doc 45)
GRANTED IN PART AND DENIED IN PART
For the reasons described below, within seven (7) calendar days of the entry of this order, GIS Marine, LLC ("GIS") shall provide an affidavit from a representative of GIS, other than its counsel, that after diligent search all documents responsive to Michael Cheese's second request for discovery have been produced. GIS shall produce the person making this affidavit as one of its Rule 30(b)(6) representatives.
GIS shall produce its corporate representatives in New Orleans for a deposition. The deposition shall take place at the office of counsel for GIS. The deposition shall be limited to seven hours exclusive of reasonable breaks. Counsel for the parties shall meet-and-confer in good faith on the scheduling of the deposition.
Within seven (7) calendar days of the entry of this order, the parties shall notify the undersigned of the agreed date for the deposition. If they cannot agree on the date for the deposition, within the same deadline they shall submit separate proposals. The Court will select the one that most nearly meets the needs of the case. The Court will enter an order scheduling the deposition for either the agreed date or the date selected by the Court. Barring a natural disaster, there will no circumstances under which the deposition will be rescheduled. At least 48 hours prior to the deposition, counsel for both parties shall provide the GIS representatives with pre-marked exhibits. The representatives shall not be questioned on any document unless it was submitted to the representatives as a pre-marked exhibit at least 48 hours in advance of the deposition. If any counsel cannot attend the deposition for any reason, the counsel shall participate by telephone. Counsel for GIS shall make the arrangements to permit the deposition to proceed by telephone if necessary.
If because of the rescheduled deposition either party contends that the District Judge's scheduling order must be modified, the deadline for such a motion is seven (7) calendar days from the entry of this order. A motion to modify the District Judge's scheduling order shall be addressed to the District Judge.
All other relief sought by the parties is denied.
On April 7, 2014, the plaintiff, Michael Cheese ("Cheese"), in CA 15-1133 was injured while employed on the vessel belonging to GIS. It filed a limitation proceeding. Rec. doc. 1. Cheese file an answer and claim. Rec. doc. 11. The final pretrial conference is set for September 25, 2015. The trial is set for October 5, 2015. Rec. doc. 22. Cheese's motion to extend some deadlines was granted with new deadlines as follows: (1) plaintiff's expert report - July 29, 2015; (2) defendant's expert report - August 27, 2015; (3) witness and exhibit lists - August 27, 2015; and (4) motion deadline - September 16, 2015. Rec. doc. 32. The District Judge's order extending deadlines provides that "[t]he parties are instructed to cooperate and work diligently to complete the necessary discovery in this matter. Failure to comply may result in sanctions pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P. 37." Rec. doc. 32.
Within two weeks of the order extending the deadlines, Cheese filed a motion for a status conference concerning a dispute over the scheduling of the depositions of Steve Degestrom, the captain of the vessel, and the Rule 30(b)(6) representatives of GIS. Rec. doc. 35. On June 22, 2015, an order was issued scheduling Degestrom's deposition on July 7, 2015 and GIS Rule 30(b)(6) representatives on July 9, 2015. Rec. doc. 38. A week later Cheese moved for reconsideration because his counsel was unavailable on July 9, 2015. Rec. doc. 39. An order was issued requiring submissions from the parties on their availability for the deposition. Rec. doc. 40. The Court was notified that the parties reached agreement on the date for the deposition of the of the Rule 30(b)(6) representatives. Rec. doc. 43. Degestrom was deposed on July 7, 2015.
The parties agreed to take the deposition of the GIS Rule 30(b)(6) representatives on Friday, July 10, 2015. On the evening before the deposition, Cheese notified GIS that his counsel would not appear to depose the GIS Rule 30(b)(6) representatives. On July 9, 2015, Cheese filed a deficient motion for a protective order. Rec. doc. 44. On July 10, 2015, counsel for GIS via email sought the Court's aid in requiring the depositions to proceed. On July 10, 2015, Cheese refiled the motion for a protective order. The Court was not available for a conference on July 10, 2015.
Cheese's motion for a protective order was reset for July 20, 2015. Rec. doc. 47. GIS filed an opposition. Rec. doc. 48. ...